FAQ

Garment Sample Approval Process: How to Evaluate and Approve Samples From Your Factory

July 19, 2026Linh Nguyen
Hands measure a beige garment with a tape measure beside technical fashion sketches and folded fabric on a worktable.

Approving a garment sample is not just a formality — it is the moment you legally and commercially authorize what the factory will produce in bulk. Once you send a written approval, the factory produces thousands of units matching that sample. If the sample has unresolved issues and you approve it anyway, those issues appear in every unit in your order. The sample approval process deserves serious, systematic attention, not a quick glance and an email saying "looks fine."

This guide walks through exactly how to evaluate a garment sample at each development stage — what to check, how to measure, how to write structured feedback, and how to determine when a sample is genuinely ready to approve.

---

## The Mindset: What Sample Approval Actually Means

When you send a factory "approved," you're saying: "Produce my order to match this sample." The factory will take your approved sample, put it on the production floor as the reference garment, and tell every worker: make it like this.

This means: - Every unresolved quality issue in the approved sample will appear in bulk - Every measurement that's slightly off in the approved sample will be replicated across every unit in your size range - Every wrong trim component or label error in an approved sample will persist to bulk unless explicitly noted

**What "approved" is not:** - "Good enough for now, fix it in production" - "I like the design, we'll deal with the construction issues later" - "Basically right, please make the changes without sending another sample"

If an issue must be resolved before bulk is acceptable, that issue must be verified in a sample — not assumed to be corrected in production.

---

## What to Evaluate at Each Sample Stage

### Evaluating the Proto Sample

The proto evaluation focuses on **design and construction direction** — not final quality details, since the proto is often made in substitute fabric.

**What to check at proto stage:**

**Overall Silhouette and Fit:** - Put the garment on a fit form (dress form) or have someone try it on - Does the overall silhouette match your design intent? - Shoulder placement correct? - Length proportions: body length, sleeve length, hem position — all in correct ratio? - Pocket placement: visually balanced and functional?

**Construction Approach:** - Are the seam types correct? (Flatlock vs. overlock vs. single needle — does the type match your spec?) - Hood construction: correct shape, center seam alignment, even left/right - Collar: sits flat, even height, no curl - Drawcord: functional, exits at correct position, even on both sides

**What to defer at proto stage:** - Color accuracy (proto is typically in substitute fabric color) - Label content (proto often uses placeholder labels) - Exact GSM compliance (substitute fabric) - Packaging (proto is not packaged)

**Proto feedback format:** Write clear, location-specific feedback. "Fix the hood" is not actionable. "Reduce hood height by 2cm at center back; reshape curves to be more rounded" is actionable.

---

### Evaluating the PP Sample (Most Critical)

The PP sample evaluation is the most important quality checkpoint in the development cycle. At this stage, you are evaluating the actual production-ready garment: correct bulk fabric, correct trims, correct labels, made by production workers (not sample room).

**Full PP Evaluation Checklist:**

#### 1. Fabric Evaluation - [ ] **Color vs. approved lab dip:** Under D65 daylight lighting, compare shell fabric to your approved lab dip color standard. Grey scale rating must be ≥4.0 (4 or 5 out of 5) for approval. - [ ] **Color consistency:** Front vs. back vs. sleeve panels — no visible shade variation within the single garment - [ ] **Fabric surface:** No holes, stains, snags, pulled loops, or weave defects - [ ] **GSM:** Weigh a 100cm² circle-cut from the garment. Calculate: weight (grams) × 100 = GSM. Must be within ±5gsm of specified weight. - [ ] **Fabric hand-feel:** Does the fabric feel like the spec? Is the brushed interior (if specified) present and evenly done?

#### 2. Construction Evaluation - [ ] **Seam type:** Check each major seam (shoulder, side, sleeve) — correct stitch type per tech pack? - [ ] **Stitch density:** Count stitches per inch on 3 seam locations. Minimum per spec. - [ ] **Seam puckering:** Pull seam flat. Does it lay flat or pucker under tension? - [ ] **Topstitching:** Parallel, even width, correct distance from edge throughout full length - [ ] **Zipper:** Open and close 5 times. No catching. Pull in correct direction. Bottom stop secure. - [ ] **Buttons:** Pull test — buttons should not detach under firm hand pull - [ ] **Thread trimming:** No loose threads at any seam or corner. Flip garment inside out to check. - [ ] **Pressing:** Garment evenly pressed. No iron marks, shine, or press creases. - [ ] **Hood:** Correct shape, center seam aligned, no puckering on curved seams - [ ] **Drawcord:** Exits at correct position; correct length extending each side; stopper functional

#### 3. Measurement Evaluation (Full POM Check) Measure every Point of Measure using a tape measure (laid flat, not stretched):

**Measurement evaluation method:** 1. Lay garment flat on a clean surface 2. Smooth garment without stretching 3. Measure each POM as defined in your measurement chart 4. Record actual measurement vs. spec vs. tolerance 5. Flag any POM outside tolerance

**If measurements are outside tolerance:** Classify as FAIL. Do not approve with "please fix in production" — the pattern must be corrected and a new PP (or at minimum a size check) conducted.

**Sample measurement record format:** ``` | POM | Spec (M) | Tolerance | Actual | Result | |------------------------|----------|-----------|--------|--------| | Chest width (laid flat)| 54 cm | ±1.5 cm | 55 cm | PASS | | Body length (HPS–hem) | 72 cm | ±1.5 cm | 71.5 cm| PASS | | Shoulder width | 48 cm | ±1.5 cm | 46.5 cm| FAIL | | Sleeve length (CB-cuff)| 87 cm | ±1.5 cm | 87 cm | PASS | ```

#### 4. Trims and Labels Evaluation - [ ] **Main label:** Correct brand name, correct "Made in Vietnam" text, woven correctly with no fraying, correct placement (CB neck, correct cm from collar) - [ ] **Care label:** Correct fiber content percentage, correct care symbols (washing temp, drying, ironing), "Made in Vietnam" present, correct destination market symbols - [ ] **Size label:** Correct size (M for size M sample), correct format (alpha vs. numeric) - [ ] **Zipper brand and spec:** Confirm brand (YKK or specified equivalent), gauge (#3, #5, #8), color and finish - [ ] **Buttons:** Correct size (mm), material (brass, ABS, etc.), color - [ ] **Drawcord:** Correct diameter (mm), material (cotton, polyester), color; correct length and tipping - [ ] **Hang tag:** Correct design, correct content; correct attachment (safety pin, string) - [ ] **Embroidery/print (if applicable):** Correct logo design, correct colors, correct placement per tech pack

#### 5. Branding Evaluation If the PP sample includes branding elements (embroidery, screen print, heat transfer): - [ ] **Artwork accuracy:** Logo matches approved artwork file; no missing elements - [ ] **Color accuracy:** Pantone match (for screen print) or thread color (for embroidery) vs. approved reference - [ ] **Placement:** Measure placement from reference point vs. spec - [ ] **Quality:** Embroidery well-digitized (no gaps, no pull, correct density); screen print fully bonded (no cracking or peeling at corners)

---

## How to Write a Factory Feedback Email

A good feedback email is structured, specific, and actionable. It eliminates ambiguity so the factory can execute corrections without a back-and-forth.

**Feedback email structure:**

``` Subject: [Brand] PP Sample Feedback — [Style Name] — [Date]

To: [Factory contact name]

Hi [Name],

Thank you for the PP sample received [date]. We have completed our evaluation.

OVERALL RESULT: CONDITIONAL / FAIL / APPROVED (with comments)

=== ITEMS REQUIRING CORRECTION ===

ITEM 1 — [Location: e.g., SHOULDER WIDTH MEASUREMENT] Issue: Shoulder width measured 46.5cm. Spec is 48cm ±1.5cm. Actual is 1.5cm below minimum tolerance. Required: Adjust pattern to achieve 48cm ±1.0cm on next sample. Classification: Major defect — cannot approve as-is.

ITEM 2 — [Location: e.g., CARE LABEL] Issue: Care label shows "100% Cotton" — correct fiber content is "80% Cotton / 20% Polyester" Required: Correct fiber content on care label. Please confirm revised label content before printing bulk labels. Classification: Critical compliance error — must be corrected.

ITEM 3 — [Location: e.g., HOOD DRAWCORD] Issue: Drawcord exits are uneven — left side 12cm, right side 9cm extended length. Required: Both sides should extend 10cm ±1cm when hood is fully closed and stopper is at cord exit. Classification: Minor — acceptable if corrected in PP2 sample.

=== ITEMS NOTED BUT ACCEPTED ===

NOTE 1 — [Location: e.g., INSIDE SEAM FINISHING] Issue: Interior seam edge not fully encased on left side seam for approximately 3cm near waistband. Decision: Accepted — minor, in non-visible area. Please ensure better seam finishing in production.

=== ITEMS CONFIRMED CORRECT ===

- Color vs. lab dip: PASS — Rating 4.5/5 under D65 lighting - Zipper function: PASS — opens and closes smoothly, no catching - Logo embroidery: PASS — matches approved file, correct placement - Fabric GSM: PASS — measured 298gsm vs. 300gsm spec (+2gsm) - Main label: PASS — correct content and placement - Stitch density: PASS — 12 SPI confirmed

=== REQUIRED ACTION ===

Please send PP2 sample addressing Items 1, 2, and 3 above. Revised sample requested by: [Date — 10 working days from today]

Please confirm receipt of this feedback and ETA for PP2 sample.

Thank you, [Name] [Brand] ```

---

## Determining If a Sample Is Ready to Approve

Use this decision framework:

**APPROVE when:** - All measurements within tolerance - No critical defects (label content, safety, functional failures) - Major defects: zero, or only documented and accepted items that are genuinely minor - Color within approved grey scale rating (≥4.0) - All required trims and labels correct - Any previously outstanding issues from proto/fit rounds are resolved

**CONDITIONAL APPROVE when:** - One or two minor items outstanding that can be verified in production without a sample - Items are documented in written approval email with specific requirements - Buyer accepts risk of not re-sampling these items

**FAIL / REQUEST PP ROUND when:** - Any measurement outside tolerance - Any critical label or compliance error - Any systematic construction defect (wrong seam type, wrong stitch density throughout) - Color rating below 3.5/5 - Wrong fabric or missing trim component

---

## How Garmentix Handles Sample Approval

Garmentix's sample approval protocol:

**With each sample, Garmentix provides:** - Full measurement record (all POMs, actual vs. spec) - Photo documentation of each key construction detail - Color evaluation note (lab dip comparison) - Defect log if any issues found

**Turnaround for PP sample corrections:** - Most measurement corrections: 3–5 working days for second PP - Label corrections: immediate (labels reprinted); PP2 in 5 working days - Pattern corrections: 5–7 working days

**Buyer's approval email is required in writing before bulk production starts.** Verbal confirmation or WhatsApp message is not sufficient for production authorization.

Contact: info@ttgco.net | garmentix.net

---

*Garmentix | Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam | info@ttgco.net | garmentix.net* *OEM/ODM Manufacturer | Proto in 7 Working Days | PP Sample Review Supported | MOQ from 200 pcs*

Linh Nguyen

Head of Quality Control, TT Garment Trade

8 years in garment QC and compliance. Certified BSCI and OEKO-TEX auditor specializing in defect classification, AQL sampling, and factory certification processes.